Pets Best rating (Elite policy): 5 out of 5 stars Best for: Overall Pets Best topped Yahoo Finance’s evaluation of the best pet insurance companies thanks to its unparalleled combination of competitive average costs and extensive coverage. There are three Pets Best policies to choose from, each with slightly different coverage details and costs: Essential, Plus, and Elite. The Elite plan scored five stars in our evaluation, and the Plus (4.7 stars) and Essential (4.6 stars) policies were also top rat ...